Tripad Visor: Why Should We Get Rid Of The Electoral College

Monday, January 6, 2020

Why Should We Get Rid Of The Electoral College

The Fourteenth Amendment 1868 which barred unpardoned rebels from becoming electors and requiring that states allow all of their male citizens over 21 years old to vote for electors. 1 The Distribution of Electoral College Votes Per State is Not Equally Dispersed The Electoral College was created in part to make the states feel important in a federalist government.

It S Time To Get Rid Of The Electoral College By Team Warren Medium

People are more important than states.

Why should we get rid of the electoral college. In a liberal democracy not. The central issue with the Electoral College is not the disproportionate amount of power given to smaller states. People have inalienable rights.

The first problem with its elimination is purely. History shows that it is certainly possible to change the method of electing a president -- we need only look at the Twelfth Amendment 1804 which mandated that electors vote separately for president and vice president. One study found that it is possible to win the electoral college by amassing just over 50 of.

On March 18 at a CNN town hall in Jackson Miss Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts called for shutting down the Electoral College. The Twenty-Third Amendment which expanded the Electoral College. Why We Should Never Ever Abolish The Electoral College.

We should absolutely scrap it. Should we get rid of it. The public generally agrees.

Getting rid of the electoral college means a vote is a vote no matter where it is. It is true that the Electoral College no longer serves its original purposes and that it creates a grave risk that a candidate not favored by a majority of the people will from time to time be elected president. Since 1944 large majorities of Americans support amending the Constitution so the presidential candidate that receives the most total votes nationwide wins the election see graph below.

I believe we need a constitutional amendment that. But with attempts at its destruction in 2005 and 2016as well as Trumps loss of the popular vote in the last electionsome Americans are now asking the question Do we still need it. After all Electoral College winners have only lost the national popular vote five.

The Electoral College has long been a hallmark of American democracy. But thats not an argument for getting rid of the electoral college nor does it address the reasons people are mistakenly focusing on it. Its time to replace it with a national popular vote.

The result as weve now seen twice in the last two decades is that a popular vote loser can be an Electoral College winner. There have been three. Getting rid of the Electoral College would be the same as turning the election over to those states with the highest populations.

In sum the Electoral College is an unwieldy institution that stands in the way of progress. Voters in all 50 states cast ballots for local state and congressional offices that directly influence election outcomes. The Electoral College is undemocratic.

The following five reasons to abolish the Electoral College are offered by supporters of using a different approach to presidential elections. A vote in Idaho is meaningless to a Democratic candidate now but it would be worth just as much as one in a swing state if we get rid of the electoral college. As discussed above the only practical way of ending the Electoral College is by changing the ways in which states use the popular vote to award electors to the presidential candidates.

Someone Can Be President With Just 218 of the Vote. Match Direct Elections at Local and State Level. Rich M Current Events November 10 2016 61 Comments Print This Article.

But the Electoral College is still a fundamentally anti-majoritarian anti-democratic institution. John Quincy Adams Benjamin Harrison and.

Book Review Why Do We Still Have The Electoral College By Alexander Keyssar Usapp